Predictive factors of death in neonates with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy receiving selective head cooling

Article information

Clin Exp Pediatr. 2021;64(4):180-187

Publication date (electronic) : 2020 August 27

doi : https://doi.org/10.3345/cep.2019.01382

Behnaz Basiri, MD¹, Mohammadkazem Sabzehei, MD¹, Mohammadmahdi sabahi, MD, MPH^,2

¹Department of Pediatrics, Hamadan University of Medical Sciences, Hamadan, Iran

²Neurosurgery Research Group (NRG), Student Research Committee, Hamadan University of Medical Sciences, Hamadan, Iran

Corresponding author: Mohammadmahdi Sabahi, MD, MPH. Neurosurgery Research Group (NRG), Student Research Committee, Hamadan University of Medical Sciences, Hamadan, Iran Email: m.sabahi@edu.umsha.ac.ir, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4640-226X

Received 2019 October 30; Revised 2020 August 1; Accepted 2020 August 11.

Abstract

Introduction

The prevalence of perinatal asphyxia in developed countries is 2 per 1,000 births, whereas it is 10 times higher in developing countries [1]. The prevalence of neonatal encephalopathy is 3 per 1,000 births, whereas that of hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) is 1.5 per 1,000 births [2]. It is well known that infants with moderate to severe HIE are at risk for adverse events, such as cerebral palsy, neurodevelopmental disorders, or death even after hypothermia. There is evidence from a large randomized controlled trial that included hypothermia is beneficial for neonates with HIE. Cooling reduces mortality without increasing major disability in survivors [3,4]. Therapeutic hypothermia is the standard treatment for infants with moderate to severe HIE [5]. Two methods are being evaluated in newborn infants with HIE: whole-body cooling and selective head cooling with mild systemic hypothermia.

In terms of prognosis, a mild form of asphyxia occurs without any neurological complications or with mild neurodevelopmental complications within 3 days. However, moderate and severe forms of asphyxia cause permanent neurological deficits and neurodevelopmental disorders [6]. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) such as diffusion tensor image can be used as a suitable standard for the determination of damage severity [7]. However, abnormal amplitude-integrated electroencephalogram (a-EEG) for 48 hours along with early abnormal MRI is a strong predictor of poor neurodevelopment [8]. Except for clinical manifestations, the use of a-EEG can be help predict brain damage of neonates following asphyxia [9].

To date, various studies have used neonatal status at birth, the severity of HIE, EEG, biomarkers, and brain MRI to predict outcome in infants with HIE [10-13]. The primary outcome of this study was to investigate the predictive factors of death in infants with HIE after selective therapeutic head cooling.

Methods

This cross-sectional descriptive-retrospective study was carried out from April 2013 to September 2018 in the Fatemieh Hospital affiliated with the Hamadan University of Medical Sciences, Iran. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Hamadan University of Medical Sciences with the code IR. UMSHA.1395.391. Written informed consent was obtained from the parent of the patient who participated in this study. Fifty-one newborns admitted to the NICU with a diagnosis of HIE, confirmed by a neonatologist, and treated with selective head cooling were enrolled in the study.

Inclusion criteria were infants with ≥36 weeks of gestational age (GA), who meet ≥1 of criteria A, B, and C, as described below [14]:

Criteria A

(1) Apgar score <5 at 10 minutes of age

(2) The continued need for ventilation 10 minutes after birth

(3) pH<7.0 or base deficit <-16 in blood gases within 1 hour of birth

Criteria B

Moderate to severe encephalopathy, consisting of altered state of consciousness (as shown by lethargy, stupor, or coma) and >1 of the following:

(1) Hypotonia

(2) Abnormal reflexes, including oculomotor or papillary abnormalities

(3) The absent or weak sucking reflex

(4) Clinical seizures

Criteria C

a-EEG records (30 minutes)

(1) Moderately abnormal a-EEG background activity

(2) Severely abnormal a-EEG background activity

(3) Seizure activity

Exclusion criteria were infants with mild HIE, over 6 hours of age at the time of admission, major congenital anomalies, head trauma causing intracranial hemorrhage, severe intrauterine growth retardation with birth weight less than 1,800 g, imperforated anus and coagulopathy with active bleeding.

HIE in the newborns was classified into 3 categories of mild, moderate, and severe based on the Sarnat staging system [15,16]. Data needed for the study, including mother’s age, newborn’s gender and weight, GA, delivery method, seizure, neonatal resuscitation, 1- and 5-minute Apgar scores, blood gas analysis, analysis of creatine phosphokinase (CPK) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) enzymes, brain imaging results, a-EEG, need for ventilator and infant outcome (death or recovery) were extracted from the patients’ medical records and recorded in a premade questionnaire.

Cool-cap (Olympic Medical Cool Care System, Olympic Medical, Seattle, WA, USA) for patients with moderate to severe HIE should begin within 6 hours of birth and continue for 72 hours.

The system consists of a cooling unit and a pump that circulate water through the cap. The initial water temperature is set between 8℃ and 12℃. All infants were placed under a radiant warmer, the temperature-controlled by an abdominal skin probe, and the rectal temperature was maintained at 34℃–35℃. At the beginning of hypothermia, the radiant warmer was switched off for 20 to 30 minutes, then restarted when the rectal temperature was reduced to 35.5℃. Slow rewarming to normal temperature was performed at the end of the 72 hours cooling period that lasts 4 hours [3].

a-EEG was used for 20 minutes to aid in the diagnosis of moderate to severe encephalopathy [11,17]. We classified infants if they had a background a-EEG voltage that was normal (upper margin >10 μV and lower margin >5 μV), moderately abnormal (upper margin >10 μV and lower margin <5 μV), or severely abnormal (upper margin <10 μV and lower margin <5μV), seizures identified by a sudden increase in voltage accompanied by narrowing of the margin of a-EEG activity followed by a brief period of suppression, or both [18]. Clinical and/or a-EEG detected seizures were treated according to standard neonatal seizure protocol. Brain imaging (cranial ultrasound and MRI) was performed. Advanced neonatal resuscitation was defined as basic resuscitation plus endotracheal intubation, chest compression, and administration of epinephrine/volume as needed.

The data were analyzed using SPSS ver. 16.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL., USA). In the inferential statistics section, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was used to examine the normal distribution of quantitative variables and the variables were compared using the chi-square test, the t test, and Mann-Whitney Utest.

Results

Fifty-one infants with asphyxia were treated with therapeutic hypothermia using the selective head cooling. The mean GA and birth weight were 38.3±1.6 weeks and 3,132±477 g. Seizure, mechanical ventilation, and severely abnormal a-EEG were observed in 22, 31, and 20 neonates, respectively. Sixteen infants (31%) died. The general characteristics of the studied neonates are presented in Table 1. Comparison of the survive and nonsurvive infants in terms of predictor factors associated with the death of the infants with asphyxia who received cool-cap therapy indicated that there were significant relationships between death and advanced neonatal resuscitation (P=0.002), mechanical ventilation (P=0.016), 1-minute Apgar score (P=0.040), and severely abnormal a-EEG (P=0.047) (Table 2). Multiple regression was performed simultaneously which indicated that only neonatal resuscitation was an independent factor associated with infant death (P=0.0075). The results of the odds ratio showed that the chances of dying among resuscitated newborns were 23.55 times higher than those among infants who were not resuscitated (Table 3).

Table 1.

General characteristics of the neonates with asphyxia treated with topical hypothermia

Table 2.

Comparison of clinical characteristics of the live and dead newborns

Table 3.

Multivariate regression analysis

In terms of staging damage severity, 26 of the 51 neonates (51%) who received selective head cooling treatment were in stage 2 and 25 (49%) in stage 3. The general characteristics of the newborns are given in Table 4. According to the results, there were significant relationships between the need for mechanical ventilation (P=0.008) and severely abnormal a-EEG (P=0.0001) and asphyxia severity (Table 5). In univariate analysis, parameters related to the asphyxia severity were considered independent, and simultaneous multiple regression was performed which indicated that only severely abnormal EEG was related to asphyxia severity (P=0.0001). The results of the odds ratio showed that the chance of stage 3 to stage 2 in neonates with severely abnormal a-EEG was 63 times higher than in neonates with normal a-EEG, and severely abnormal a-EEG was an independent predictor of asphyxia severity (Table 6).

Table 4.

Characteristics of the newborns by damage severity

Table 5.

Effective factors associated with the damage severity of neonates with asphyxia

Table 6.

Multivariate regression analysis

Discussion

In this study, the comparison of surviving and nonsurviving newborns showed that neonatal advanced resuscitation, need for mechanical ventilation, lower 1-minute Apgar score, and severe abnormalities in a-EEG increased the risk of mortality in newborns with HIE.

Fifty-one neonates with moderate to severe HIE treated with selective head cooling in the present study and 16 infants (31.3%) died. Shankaran et al. [19] demonstrated 24% in the hypothermia group and 37% in the control group died. According to studies by Srinivasakumar et al. [20] and Gluckman et al. [11], hypothermia appears to be less protective in infants with the most severe HIE. All cases of neonatal death in our study were severe HIE (stage 3). Thus, one of the reasons for the high mortality rate in our study compared to the study of Shankaran et al. [19] was the high rate of patients with severe HIE, 49% versus 32% respectively [19]. As a result, head cooling reduces neonatal death compared to routine care.

Regarding the effect of the lower Apgar score at birth, other studies showed that acidemia and lower Apgar scores were associated with a worse outcome of HIE infants [21,22]. This is while indications for hypothermia therapy include a-EEG, Apgar score, the neurologic score for encephalopathy, pH, and lactate levels [23]. In another study, metabolic acidosis was observed only in infants with grade 3 HIE [24]. In our study, the mean pH in HIE infants was 7.3 in grade 2 and 7.25 in grade 3, indicating that the level of acidosis was higher in infants with grade 3 HIE.

In our study, the mean values of arterial PH were higher than in other studies and there was no significant difference between mean value of arterial PH and infant death and staging of HIE. These differences may be due to different time of sampling. In our study, umbilical cord arterial blood gas analysis at birth was not performed and atrial blood gas sampling was taken at least half an hour later after birth and after initial stabilization of neonates. Umbilical cord arterial blood gas analysis is a simple, accurate, and reliable tool for diagnosing asphyxia because of HIE is hypoxic events and metabolic acidosis. Therefore, the results of umbilical cord arterial blood gas analysis at birth are a gold standard that reflects blood gas and basal acid status immediately before birth [25]. Among the parameters of arterial blood gas, umbilical cord pH is the most important factor and the severity of acidosis is related to the severity of the injury [26] but in another study, it was noted that umbilical cord gas alone has its limitations and cannot be used as the sole indicator for the diagnosis of HIE. For this reason, the combination of umbilical artery pH and Apgar score to overcome these limitations was used [27,28]. Williams' study showed that there was no correlation between pH and neonatal death in infants with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy that These findings same with ours and differ from those of majority of researchers [29].

The results of the multiple regression analysis of the study data showed that only the advanced neonatal resuscitation (including endotracheal intubation, chest compression, and epinephrine/volume administration) was an independent factor associated with the death of the newborns. The results of the odds ratio showed that the chances for the neonatal death were 23.55 times higher than those of the infants who were not resuscitated. Another study indicated that 107 of the 4,629 newborns (or 2.3%) needed neonatal resuscitation, and the need for advanced neonatal resuscitation was significantly related to death in newborns with asphyxia [30]. It was demonstrated in another study that after implementation of the neonatal resuscitation program (NRP), the number of newborns with asphyxia who were not resuscitated and the length of stay decreased significantly, while the 1-minute Apgar score increased [31]. Regarding this increase in the Apgar score and advantages and disadvantages of resuscitation in neonates with asphyxia, it should be noted that resuscitation conditions including 100% oxygenation for the resuscitation of asphyxia infants [32] and appropriate training of resuscitators in developing countries on the correct implementation of the NRP can improve the possible complications [33]. A study on 60 neonates with HIE (including 39 infants with moderate to severe HIE) showed that neonatal clinical markers, including Apgar score and neonatal resuscitation, were better predictors for HIE than biochemical markers such as placental artery pH, base excess, and lactate level. Consistent with our study, neonatal resuscitation (93% sensitivity, 99% specificity) was the most effective predictor for infants with moderate to severe HIE [34].

In the present study, despite the high CPK and LDH levels, the severity of damage and death in HIE infants had no statistically significant relationships with these 2 enzymes. Beken et al. [35] found that serum creatine kinase BB was much higher in infants who died due to severe HIE and that biomarker changes occurred before the clinical presentation. In addition, although LDH and lactate levels increase significantly during HIE progression, they have no high predictive value in advanced HIE (stages 2 and 3). Since the neonates in the present study were at stages 2 and 3, no significant relationship was found between their mortality and high levels of LDH and lactate, which indicated the conformity of these studies. In addition, LDH levels were higher in the saliva of HIE infants than in that of the control group [36]. Finally, it can be said that none of these metabolic and biochemical markers are prioritized over a-EEG and Sarnat score for predicting HIE [6].

The most accurate tool for assessing the severity of postnatal neurological damage in neonates with HIE is continuous 2-channel EEG [17]. In the current study, the a-EEG analysis in infants with HIE showed that 31.3%, 11.8%, 17.6%, and 39.2% of the neonates had normal, moderately abnormal, moderately to severely abnormal, and severely abnormal EEG, respectively. In terms of the EEG value, the background EEG pattern can predict neurological complications for term infants with HIE, whereas concomitance of EEG with clinical data such as GA, birth weight, brain imaging, and severity of HIE can provide a more accurate assessment of neurological complications [8,37]. Moreover, in infants with HIE who are treated with therapeutic hypothermia using a cool cap, severe abnormality in EEG is associated with brain tissue damage in MRI and predicts neurodevelopmental complications in these neonates. EEG abnormality has also a high positive predictive value for the selection of HIE newborns who can benefit from adjuvant therapies [38].

Srinivasakumar et al. [20] demonstrated therapeutic hypothermia was associated with a decrease in electroconvulsive seizures in neonates with moderate HIE, but not in those with severe HIE, which is similar to the results of our study. Gluckman et al. [11] reported that selective head cooling in neonatal encephalopathy improves survival without severe neurological disability in infants with less severe a-EEG changes. Nanavati et al. [12] also showed that EEG changes can be used as predictors of the outcome in infants with HIE.

In the present study, there were significant correlations between the severity of HIE in neonates and the need for mechanical ventilation and 55% of newborns who underwent mechanical ventilation died. Atıcı et al. [39] demonstrated 94% of HIE infants during the cooling process require mechanical ventilation and no differences were found between the 2 cooling methods. The involvement of other organs, including the lung, worsens the prognosis of neonatal HIE. For this reason, mechanical ventilation is an independent factor in neonatal mortality.

Head cooling for all patients in our study began less than 4 hours after birth to achieve the desired effect. However, our study has some limitations, some clinical data not reported in detail because it had a retrospective design. This does not include infants with mild HIE.

In conclusion, this study showed that all cases of neonatal death in our study were severe HIE (stage 3). Advanced neonatal resuscitation was an independent predictor of death and severely abnormal a-EEG was an independent predictive factor of asphyxia severity in infants with HIE.

Article information Continued