< Previous Next >
Article Contents
Clin Exp Pediatr > Volume 60(9); 2017 |
|
Conflicts of interest:
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
Methods | Pharyngeal administration | Aerosolized administration | LMA-guided administration | Thin catheter administration |
---|---|---|---|---|
Studies | Ten Centre Study Group32), 1987* | Jorch et al.34), 1997 | Brimacombe et al.38), 2004† | Verder et al.44), 1992 |
Dambeanu et al.33), 1997* | Arroe et al.35), 1998 | Trevisanuto et al.27), 2005† | Kribs et al.28,29,45), 2007, 2008, 2010 | |
Kattwinkel et al.25), 2004 | Berggren et al.26), 2000* | Micaglio et al.39), 2008† | Göpel et al.46), 2011* | |
Finer et al.36), 2010 | Barbosa et al.40), 2012† | Dargaville et al.47,48), 2011, 2013 | ||
Minocchieri et al.37), 2013* | Attridge et al.41), 2013* | Mehler et al.49), 2012 | ||
Sadeghnia et al.42), 2014* | Kanmaz et al.50), 2013* | |||
Pinheiro et al.43), 2016* | Klebermass-Schrehof et al.24), 2013 | |||
Heidarzadeh et al.51), 2013* | ||||
Aguar et al.52), 2014 | ||||
Kribs et al.53), 2015* | ||||
Mohammadizadeh et al.54), 2015* | ||||
Bao et al.55), 2015* | ||||
Krajewski et al.56), 2015 | ||||
Göpel et al.57), 2015 | ||||
Canals Candela et al.58), 2016 |
Study | Design and population | Control | Intervention | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ten Centre Study Group32), 1987 | RCT; GA, 25–29 wk | Saline |
43 I and 32 C: 25–26 wk; 116 I and 117 C: 27–29 wk |
Mortality: 19% I vs. 30% C (P<0.01) Respiratory support in first 10 day: I group, 19 hr less in >30% oxygen (P<0.05) and 20 hr less ventilation (P<0.05) |
Dambeanu et al.33), 1997 | RCT; GA 28–33 wk | Routine assistance | 28 I and 25 C |
Mortality: 42.8 I vs. 48% C (P=NS) IVH: high in both group Silverman score significantly reduced in 1st 24 hr |
Kattwinkel et al.25), 2004 | Nonrandomized feasibility study; GA 27–30 wk; BW 560–1,804 g |
N=23 Infasurf CPAP of 10 cmH2O by mask → 6 cmH2O for 48 hr |
VD: 13 of 15 babies weaned quickly to RA, no further surfactant or ET for RDS CS: 5 of 8 required subsequent ET soon after birth, 2 received subsequent ET surfactant |
RCT, randomized controlled trial; GA, gestational age, I, intervention group; C, control group; NS, nonspecific; IVH, intraventricular hemorrhage; BW, birth weight; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; VD, vaginal delivery; RA, room air; ET, endotracheal; RDS, respiratory distress syndrome; CS, c-section.
Study | Design and population | Control | Intervention | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Jorch et al.34), 1997 | Nonrandomized multicenter pilot study; GA, 28–35 wk; On CPAP 1–7 hr of age | No | Alveofact (n=20); jet nebulizer 150 mg/kg x2, total 300 mg/kg, loading amount within 20–50 min |
Significant (A-a)DO2 improvement after first 150-mg/kg dose Improvement in Silvermann score Improvement in PaCO2 |
Arroe et al.35), 1998 | Nonrandomized pilot study; GA, 23–36 wk; RDS, <3 day | No | Exosurf (n=22); jet nebulizer groups 1–4: 1, 2, 4, or 8 vial 2 tx. of 30 min, 6 hr apart | 8 Patients required IMV up to 2 hr after last tx; No adverse effects; No improvement in clinical variables or (A-a)DO2; Application of treatment too late |
Berggren et al.26), 2000 | RCT; GA, 27–34 wk; randomized at 2–36 hr; FiO2 >0.4 | CPAP (3–5 cmH2O) alone | Curosurf (n=34), jet nebulizer 16 C and 16 I (porcine surfactant, 480 mg) |
Need for MV: 38% C vs. 31% I (P=NS); BPD: 12.5% C vs. 0% I (P=NS) No side effects noted; No beneficial effects noted |
Finer et al.36), 2010 | Feasibility and safety study; GA, 28–32 wk; RDS | No | Aerosurf (n=17), vibrating membrane nebulizer; Randomized to group 1: at least 3 hr apart; group 2 at least 1 hr apart | All infants survived; 29.4% ET surfactant replacement; 23.5% RDS at 24 hr; 11.8% BPD at 28 day; Mean FiO2 0.4 at baseline; 0.32 at 4 hr posttreatment |
Minocchieri et al.37), 2013 | RCT; GA, 29–33 wk; FiO2, 0.22–0.30 in first 6 hr after birth | CPAP alone | N=64; I (porcine surfactant) vs. C; vibrating membrane nebulizer | Need for intubation in the first 72 hr: RR, 0.56 (95% CI, 0.34–0.93); BPD: no difference |
Segal et al., ongoing | RCT; GA 29–34 wk; ≤21 hr | CPAP alone | CPAP+Lucinactant (3 doses) (n=48) | |
Sood et al., ongoing | RCT; GA, 24–36 wk; ≤24 hr | 100 vs. 200 | Survanta;100 vs. 200 mg phospholipid/kg (n=120) |
GA, gestational age; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; (A-a)DO2, alveolar-arterial oxygen difference; RDS, respiratory distress syndrome; IMV, intermittent mandatory ventilation; tx, treatment; RCT, randomized controlled trial; C, control group; I, intervention group; MV, mechanical ventilation; BPD, bronchopulmonary dysplasia; ET, endotracheal; FiO2, a fraction of inspired oxygen; RR, relative risk; CI, confidence interval.
Study | Design and Population | Control | Intervention | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Brimacombe et al.38), 2004 | Case reports: GA 30 and 37 wk; BW 1,360 and 3,200 g respectively | Surfactant administered via Classic LMA | Successful uses | |
Trevisanuto et al.27), 2005 | Nonrandomized feasibility study; GA ≤35 wk; BW >800 g; ≤72 hr, a/APO2 <0.20 | CPAP, 5 cmH2O | Surfactant administered via LMA without sedation or analgesia (n=8) | 3 hr after surfactant instillation: mean (A-a)DO2 increased (0.13±0.04 to 0.34±0.11; P<0.01) without complications |
Micaglio et al.39), 2008 | Case reports: GA 37, 34, and 32 wk; BW 3,500, 2,050, and 1,530 g respectively | ProSeal LMA | Successful uses | |
Barbosa et al.40), 2012 | Case report: GA 31 wk, BW 1,335 g | ProSeal LMA | Successful use | |
Attridge et al.41), 2013 | RCT; BW≥1,200 g; age at inclusion, ≤72 hr; CPAP with FiO2 0.3 to 0.6 | CPAP alone | 13 I (calfactant surfactant, 3 mL/kg) and 13 C |
MV need within 96 hr: RR, 1.0 (95% CI, 0.25–4.07) Reduced FiO2 requirement for 1st 12 hr |
Sadeghnia et al.42), 2014 | RCT; Mean GA 35 wk, BW>2,000 g | INSURE | 35 I (Survanta, 100 mg/kg) and 35 C | Higher (A-a)DO2 after procedure in the LMA group, no further differences |
Pinheiro et al.43), 2016 | RCT; GA 27–36 wk; BW >800 g; 2–48 hr; ≥ 5 cmH2O, FiO2 0.3–0.6 (n=130) | INSURE | Surfactant via LMA | Failure rate 77% in control group vs. 30% in intervention group, mainly caused by differences in early failure |
Roberts et al, ongoing | RCT; GA 28–35 wk; ≤36 hr; 6 cmH2O, FiO2≥ 0.3 (n=144) | CPAP alone | Surfactant via LMA+CPAP | Intubation/MV in 1st 7 days |
LMA, laryngeal mask airway; GA, gestational age; BW, birth weight; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; (A-a)DO2, alveolar-arterial oxygen difference; RCT, randomized controlled trial; I, intervention group; C, control group; MV, mechanical ventilation; RR, relative risk; FiO2, a fraction of inspired oxygen; INSURE, intubation, surfactant and extubation.
Method | Study | Catheter | Magill forceps used | Dose and mode of surfactant delivery | Premedication |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cologne method | Kribs et al.28), 2007 | 4- to 5-FG feeding tube | Yes |
100 mg/kg Slow push, 1–3 min |
Atropine, sedation, and analgesia (optional) |
Hobart method | Dargaville et al.47,48), 2011, 2013 | 16-G Angiocath | No |
100–200 mg/kg 3–4 boluses, 15–30 sec |
Sucrose |
Take care method | Kanmaz et al.50), 2012 | 5-FG feeding tube | No |
100 mg/kg Slow bolus, 30–60 sec |
None |
Karolinska method | Bohlin (unpublished)16) | 5-FG X 30-cm catheter | No | Slow bolus, 30 sec | Atropine/fentanyl |
SONSURE method | Aguar et al.52), 2014 | 4-FG feeding tube | Yes |
100 mg/kg Slow push, 1–3 min |
Atropine, caffeine |
LISA method (Benveniste valve) | Klebermass-Schrehof et al.24), 2013 | 4-FG feeding tube | Yes |
200 mg/kg Slow push, 2–5 min |
Caffeine |
Author | Design and population | Control | Intervention | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Verder et al.44), 1992 | Nonrandomized feasibility study; | ET instillation | MIST | Successful uses |
Kribs et al.28), 2007 | Nonrandomized feasibility study; ELBW infants with GA, 23–27 wk | ET instillation (n=34) | MIST, FiO2>0.4: 100 mg/kg surfactant (n=29) |
BPD: 14% I vs. 15% C (P=NS) Mortality: 12% I vs. 35% C (P=0.025) |
Kribs et al.29), 2008 | Retrospective cohort study, ELBW | Historical control (n=51, period 0) | Period 1–4 (n=196) |
Decrease CPAP failure from 46% to 25% Survival increased significantly between periods 0 and 1 from 76% to 90% and survival without BPD rose from 65% to 80%. |
Kribs et al.45), 2010 | Prospective cohort study; VLBW infants or GA, <31 wk | ET instillation (n=1,222) | MIST (n=319) | MV in first 72 hr: 29% I vs. 53% C (P<0.001); BPD: 11% I vs. 18% C (P=0.004) |
Dargaville et al.47), 2011 | Nonrandomized feasibility study, GA 25–34 wk | CPAP, ET instillation (n=173) | MIST (n=25) | Lower FiO2 after MIST (pre-MIST: 0.39±0.092 (mean±SD); 4 hr: 0.26±0.093; P<0.01 |
Mehler et al.49), 2012 | Prospective cohort study; ELBW infants or GA, <26 wk | Historical control (n=44) | MIST (n=164) | MV 51% I vs. 72% C (P<0.05); Overall mortality 20% I vs. 39% C; BPD 18% I vs. 37% C, IVH>II 10% I vs. 33% C. |
Dargaville et al.48), 2013 | Nonrandomized study (historical controls); GA, 25–34 wk, age, <24 hr | Routine CPAP and ET Instillation (n=41: GA, 25–28 wk; 56: GA, 29–34 wk) | MIST (n=38: GA, 25–28 wk; 23: GA, 29–34 wk) |
MV at 72 hr, GA, 25-28 wk: OR, 0.21 (95% CI, 0.08-0.55); MV at 72 hr, GA, 29–34 wk: OR 0.34 (95% CI, 0.11–1.0); BPD: 29% I vs. 29% C (P=0.85) |
Klebermass-Schrehof et al.24), 2013 | Nonrandomized study (historical controls); GA, 23–27 wk, at birth |
CPAP, ET Instillation (n=182) |
MIST (n=224) | MV need at 3 day: 23% I vs. 52% C (P<0.001); BPD: 16% I vs. 12% C P=NS); death or CLD 40% I vs. 51% (P=0.03) |
Aguar et al.52), 2014 | Prospective cohort study, GA 24+0–35+6 wk, at birth | INSURE method (n=31) | MIST (n=45) | MV within 72 hr: 34% I vs. 26% C (P=0.44); a second dose of surfactant: 35% I vs. 6.5% C (P<0.0001). |
Krajewski et al.56), 2015 | Prospective cohort study, preterm infants | INSURE method (n=26) | MIST (n=26) | BPD 15.4% I vs. 40% C (P<0.05), MV 3.9% I vs. 11.7% C (P<0.05). |
Göpel et al.57), 2015 | Prospective cohort study (German Neonatal Network), GA <32 wk | CPAP, ET instillation (n=1,103) | MIST (n=1,103) | MV: 41% I vs. 62% C (P<0.001); BPD: 12% I vs. 18% C (P=0.001); BPD or death:14% vs. 21% (P<0.001). |
Canals Candela et al.58), 2016 | Prospective cohort study | CPAP, ET instillation (n=28) | MIST (n=19) | ET intubation within 72 hr 42% I vs. 54% C (P<0.05). |
ET, endotracheal; MIST, minimally invasive surfactant therapy, ELBW, extremely low birth weight; GA, gestational age; FiO2, a fraction of inspired oxygen; BPD, bronchopulmonary dysplasia; I, intervention; C, control; NS, nonspecific; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; VLBW, very low birth weight; FiO2, a fraction of inspired oxygen; SD, standard deviation; MV, mechanical ventilation; IVH, intraventricular hemorrhage; OR, odds ratio; CI, confidence interval; CLD, chronic lung disease; INSURE, intubation, surfactant and extubation.
Trial | Intubation vs. control | Gestation range | Entry criteria | Primary outcomes | Other findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Göpel et al.46), 2011 | MIST (n=108) vs. CPAP followed by ET instillation (n=112) | 26–28 wk or VLBW |
Age <12 hr FiO2>30% |
Intubation days 2–3 | MV days 2–3 28% vs 46% (NNT: 6, 95% CI: 3–20, P=0.008); intubation at any time: 33% vs 73% (P<0.001); median days on MV: 0 vs 2; Oxygen at 28 days: 30% vs 45% (P=0.032) |
Kanmaz et al.50), 2013 | MIST (n=100) vs. INSURE (n=100) | <32 wk |
Age<72 hr FiO2>40% |
Intubation <72 hr | MV within 72 hr: 30% vs. 45% (P=0.02); MV at any time: 40% vs. 49% (P=0.08); BPD: 10% vs. 20% (P=0.009) |
Heidarzadeh et al.51), 2013 | MIST (n=38) vs. INSURE (n=42) | ≤32 wk | Immediately after birth | Feasibility, description of outcomes | Lower rate of NEC and shorter duration of CPAP and hospital stay in the intervention group, no further differences |
Kribs, et al.53), 2015 | MIST (n=104) vs. CPAP, ET instillation (n=107) | 23–26 wk |
Age<2 hr FiO2≥0.30 or Silverman score ≥5 |
Survival without BPD at 36-wk GA | Survival without BPD 67.3% vs. 58.7% (P=0.20); intubation: 74.8% vs. 99.0% (P=0.04); pneumothorax: 4.8% vs. 12.6% (P=0.02); Severe IVH: 10.3% vs. 22.1% (P=0.02); survival without major complications: 50.5% vs. 35.6% (P= 0.02). |
Mohammadizadeh et al.54), 2015 | MIST (n=19) vs. INSURE (n=19) | ≤34 wk |
Age<1 hr FiO2≥0.30 or Silverman score ≥5 |
Need for MV and duration of oxygen therapy | No difference in need for MV, but duration of surfactant therapy significantly shorter in intervention group |
Bao et al.55), 2015 | MIST (n=47) vs. INSURE (n=43) | 28–32 wk |
Age<2 hr nCPAP≥7 cmH2O and FiO2≥0.3 (28+0–29+6 wk or ≥0.35 (30+0–32+6 wk) |
Feasibility, rate of MV in the first 72 hr, duration of MV, CPAP, and oxygen requirement, neonatal morbidities | No differences in rate of MV in the first 72 hr, duration of oxygen and neonatal morbidities, duration of MV and CPAP significantly less in the intervention group |
Dargaville, et al.64), ongoing | Hobart | 25–28 wk | Less than 6 hr after birth FiO2>30% | BPD or mortality |
MIST, minimally invasive surfactant therapy; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; ET, endotracheal; VLBW, very low birth weight; FiO2, a fraction of inspired oxygen; MV, mechanical ventilation; NNT, number need to treat; CI, confidence interval; INSURE, intubation, surfactant and extubation; BPD, bronchopulmonary dysplasia; NEC, necrotizing enterocolitis; GA, gestational age; IVH, intraventricular hemorrhage; nCPAP, nasal CPAP.