Warning: fopen(/home/virtual/pediatrics/journal/upload/ip_log/ip_log_2024-06.txt) [function.fopen]: failed to open stream: Permission denied in /home/virtual/pediatrics/journal/ip_info/view_data.php on line 82

Warning: fwrite(): supplied argument is not a valid stream resource in /home/virtual/pediatrics/journal/ip_info/view_data.php on line 83
The First Korean case of combined oxidative phosphorylation deficiency-17 diagnosed by clinical and molecular investigation

Volume 60(12); December

< Previous     Next >

Article Contents

Clin Exp Pediatr > Volume 60(12); 2017
Kim, Kim, Lee, and Cheon: The First Korean case of combined oxidative phosphorylation deficiency-17 diagnosed by clinical and molecular investigation


Combined oxidative phosphorylation deficiency-17 (COXPD-17) is very rare and is caused by homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations in the ELAC2 gene on chromosome 17p12. The ELAC2 gene functions as a mitochondrial tRNA processing gene, and only 4 different pathogenic mutations have been reported in ELAC2-associated mitochondrial dysfunction involving oxidative phosphorylation. Affected patients show various clinical symptoms and prognosis, depending on the genotype. We report a novel mutation in the ELAC2 gene (c.95C>G [p.Pro32Arg], het), in an infant with COXPD-17 who presented with encephalopathy including central apnea and intractable epilepsy, and growth and developmental retardation. During hospitalization, consistently elevated serum lactic acid levels were noted, indicative of mitochondrial dysfunction. The patient suddenly died of shock of unknown cause at 5 months of age. This is the first case report of COXPD-17 in Korea and was diagnosed based on clinical characteristics and genetic analysis.


Mitochondrial diseases are heterogeneous disorders, causing varying degrees of impairment in the production of adenosine triphosphate through oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) by the mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes1). Mitochondria are under dual genetic control, from mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) itself and nuclear DNA, and respiratory chain enzyme complexes of the OXPHOS system are composed of more than 70 subunits encoded by nuclear genome and 13 subunits encoded by mtDNA2,3). Isolated or combined enzyme complex deficiency presents a wide variety of clinical manifestations, and involves various inheritance patterns such as Mendelian or mitochondrial genetics, which could interfere with establishing a clear genotype of mitochondrial diseases1).
Combined oxidative phosphorylation deficiency-17 (COXPD-17) is caused by homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations in the ELAC2 gene on chromosome 17p12 (MIM No.615440). Although several mutations of ELAC2 was reported in relation to prostate cancer4), to date, only 1 compound heterozygous mutation and 3 homozygous mutations in the ELAC2 gene associated with impaired OXPHOS have been found worldwide5,6,7): c.631C>T;1559C>T(p. Arg211*;Thr520Ile), c.460T>C(p.Phe154Leu), c.1267C>T (p.Leu423 Phe), c.1423+2T>A.
Here, we present a patient with COXPD-17 associated with a novel mutation in the ELAC2 gene who exhibited central apnea, intractable epilepsy, and growth and developmental retardation.

Case report

This female patient was born at 38 weeks of gestation by caesarean section due to a fetal heart defect detected on antenatal sonography. Her mother was healthy during pregnancy without significant medical history. There was no remarkable history in each parent's family and the patient was their first baby. She showed intrauterine growth retardation. Her weight (2,350 g), height (46 cm), and head circumference (31.5 cm) were below 10th percentile. She had subtle dysmorphic features including hypertelorism, high arched palate, and both simian creases.
From the second day of birth, she presented apnea more than four times a day and her percutaneous oxygen saturation decreased during feeding. To maintain airway and support respiration, she was intubated and received mechanical ventilator therapy. For cardiac anomaly of tetralogy of Fallot, total correction operation was performed on the 36th day of hospitalization, earlier than that planned for 3 months of age, because the apnea had worsened. Despite the fact that the cardiac anomaly was corrected, sudden frequent desaturation was aggravated, and frequent seizure like motions were noticed. She had 2 types of clinical seizures several times a day, as follows: (1) sudden attack of desaturation with tonic seizures of both extremities lasting for 30 seconds to 1 minute, and (2) upper eyeball deviation with smacking her lips followed by tonic seizure of both extremities with desaturation lasting for 2 to 3 minutes. Her seizures were medically intractable, despite the adequate dose of several antiepileptic drugs including phenobarbital, topiramate, levetiracetam, vigabatrin, valproate, oxcarbazepine, zonisamide, and prednisolone.
At the age of 3 months, growth parameters such as height (53 cm), weight (4.4 kg), and head circumference (38 cm) were all below the 5th percentile. A global developmental delay seemed obvious, because she rarely showed spontaneous eye opening and movement of limbs, and did not show appropriate responses such as avoidance or crying to external stimuli. She also had muscle hypotonia. Central apnea was strongly suspected because there was no effort of spontaneous breathing by the patient. Repeated electroencephalography studies demonstrated poorly organized sleep feature, and nearly continuous asynchronous diffuse slow waves mixed with very frequent multifocal independent spike foci over the bilateral frontal and bilateral posterior head regions. The brain magnetic resonance imaging showed no clinically relevant finding.
After reviewing the medical records again, it was recognized that her arterial lactic acid levels were consistently elevated above normal levels (2.3–5.0 mmol/L, normal range<1.6 mmol/L) (Fig. 1). We further investigated, with the focus on hyperlactatemia. The results of investigations for inborn error of metabolism including tandem mass spectrometry, serum amino acid, and urine organic acid analysis, revealed no significant abnormalities. However, a blood lactic acid level of 3.8 mmol/L and pyruvic acid level of 1.3 mg/dL was found when she was in a stable condition, without any hypoxic sign. The cerebrospinal fluid lactic acid level was also elevated to 7.6 mmol/L. All characteristics and measurements were indicative of mitochondrial disease. She was supplemented with coenzyme Q10 (5 mg/kg/day), thiamine (30 mg/day), and L-carnitine (100 mg/kg/day). Although she suffered from intractable epilepsy, she was transferred to the ward in a stable condition, with a home mechanical ventilator and a feeding tube inserted through gastrostomy, at 5 months of age. However, a few days later, she suddenly showed hypotension with severe metabolic and lactic acidosis, and despite aggressive resuscitation, she died after 18 hours. As a cause of death, cardiomyopathy was excluded as a normal result of echocardiogram performed several days before her death. But, sepsis was suspected because she had an increased total leukocyte count of 41,110 cells/µL (segmented neutrophil 50%) and elevated C-reactive protein level of 13.9 mg/dL, on the day of the event, even though there were no causative microorganism were identified.
For genetic analysis, a written consent was obtained from the family. Her karyotype was normal (46, XX) and the array comparative genomic hybridization also showed no abnormalities. For the next step, targeted exome sequencing (TES) was carried out in using the NextSeq 500 sequencing platform and TruSight One Sequencing panel (Depth 94X) (Illumina, San Diego, CA, USA). The TES results revealed a heterozygous novel variant, c.95C>G (p.Pro32Arg), on ELAC2 exon 1, which was confirmed by Sanger sequencing (Fig. 2A). This variant was predicted to be damaging using the in silico analysis (SIFT 0.029, prediction: damaging, MutationTaster 0.97, prediction: disease causing). The variant was detected in the control population with a frequency of 0.24% (KRGDB). The proline at position 32 is a highly conserved amino acid residue among different species (Fig. 2B). This mutation was inherited from her father. The additional variant could not be identified by Sanger sequencing.


COXPD-17 is a very rare disease caused by mutation of the ELAC2 gene on chromosome 17p12. The ELAC2 was known only as a heritable prostate cancer-related gene4,8), until it was first reported in 2013 to be associated with impaired OXPHOS in mitochondria5). Since the synthesized mitochondrial tRNA (mt-tRNA) is an unprocessed precursor, extra nucleotides must be removed to become a mature mt-tRNA9). The 3' end of tRNAs is mainly processed by the mitochondrial RNase Z, which is encoded by the ELAC2 gene10,11). The study results by Haack et al.5) indicated that impaired RNase Z activity due to the ELAC2 mutation causes impaired OXPHOS resulting in cellular energy metabolism failure, especially by mitochondrial translation.
Notably, COXPD-17 follows an autosomal recessive inheritance pattern, but in our patient, mutation in one allele was not found. Nevertheless, we strongly believe that the identified ELAC2 gene mutation is closely correlated to the phenotype of the patient. The patient had hyperlactatemia which is indicative of mitochondrial dysfunction, and presented encephalopathy, suggesting significant involvement of brain in impaired mitochondrial function. There might be an additional mutation that has not been discovered by sequencing, because the possibility of a large deletion or duplication and an accompanying deep intronic mutation cannot be excluded.
Patients reported with ELAC2 gene mutation showed mostly severe outcome with clinical manifestations that involve organs such as the brain, heart or muscle, which require high energy metabolism (Table 1). In this case, the main clinical issue of the patient was encephalopathy presented as central apnea, intractable epilepsy, and neurodevelopmental delay. She also had a cardiac anomaly without evidence of cardiomyopathy, and died of rapid deterioration of shock suspected of being caused by sepsis. According to the previous reports, most of the deceased patients with COXPD-17 died from cardiomyopathy, and no accompanying cardiac anomalies were reported 5,6,7). Whether the cardiac anomaly in our patient was associated with COXPD-17 is unclear, it is rather thought to be less relevant given that mitochondrial dysfunction can lead to myocardial remodeling, which manifests as hypertrophic or dilated cardiomyopathy, and sepal hypertrophy12,13). In our patient, the reason for the absence of cardiomyopathy was presumably because she was in a relatively stable condition with medication and respiratory support.
In a study conducted in Saudi Arabia7), homozygous p.Phe154Leu mutation in the ELAC2 gene was found in 16 patients with severe infantile-onset cardiomyopathy, which was the same mutation as a previously reported patient5). The affected patients presented with hypertrophic or dilated cardiomyopathy between 2 and 7 months of age and all died with a median age of 4 months5,7). Moreover, 5 patients with a homozygous splicing ELAC2 mutation (c.1423+2T>A) in an Arabic inbred consanguineous family mainly presented intellectual disability, whereas cardiac involvement was not prominent, and all were alive at follow-up6). In this regard, it seems evident that the phenotype is correlated with a particular genotype of the ELAC2 mutation.
In addition, a common characteristic among the affected patients was that lactate levels were high in all patients from whom serum lactate could be obtained5,6). Hyperlactatemia without any hypoxic condition indicates mitochondrial dysfunction, and it could be a surrogate marker of mitochondrial disorders. Mitochondrial disease should be considered as a likely cause in children with unexplained neurological deficit or involvement of organs such as heart or muscle, and it would be useful to identify hyperlactatemia as the first clue for mitochondrial dysfunction in these patients. Limitation of this study is that we could not measure the enzyme activity of mitochondrial respiratory chain complex I in muscle biopsy when mutation in one allele was not detected in the patient.
In summary, this is first case with COXPD-17 in Korea, which was diagnosed by clinical and molecular investigation, and revealed to involve a novel ELAC2 gene mutation. Further study is required to understand functional and structural changes of proteins involved in this disorder and their associations with phenotypic spectrum.


This study was supported by a 2016 research grant from Pusan National University Yangsan Hospital.


Conflicts of interest:
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.


1. De Vivo DC. The expanding clinical spectrum of mitochondrial diseases. Brain Dev 1993;15:1–22.
crossref pmid
2. Ojala D, Merkel C, Gelfand R, Attardi G. The tRNA genes punctuate the reading of genetic information in human mitochondrial DNA. Cell 1980;22:393–403.
crossref pmid
3. Montoya J, Christianson T, Levens D, Rabinowitz M, Attardi G. Identification of initiation sites for heavy-strand and light-strand transcription in human mitochondrial DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1982;79:7195–7199.
crossref pmid pmc
4. Alvarez-Cubero MJ, Saiz M, Martinez-Gonzalez LJ, Alvarez JC, Lorente JA, Cozar JM. Genetic analysis of the principal genes related to prostate cancer: a review. Urol Oncol 2013;31:1419–1429.
crossref pmid
5. Haack TB, Kopajtich R, Freisinger P, Wieland T, Rorbach J, Nicholls TJ, et al. ELAC2 mutations cause a mitochondrial RNA processing defect associated with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. Am J Hum Genet 2013;93:211–223.
crossref pmid pmc
6. Akawi NA, Ben-Salem S, Hertecant J, John A, Pramathan T, Kizhakkedath P, et al. A homozygous splicing mutation in ELAC2 suggests phenotypic variability including intellectual disability with minimal cardiac involvement. Orphanet J Rare Dis 2016;11:139
crossref pmid pmc
7. Shinwari ZMA, Almesned A, Alakhfash A, Al-Rashdan AM, Faqeih E, Al-Humaidi Z, et al. The Phenotype and outcome of infantile cardiomyopathy caused by a homozygous ELAC2 mutation. Cardiology 2017;137:188–192.
crossref pmid
8. Tavtigian SV, Simard J, Teng DH, Abtin V, Baumgard M, Beck A, et al. A candidate prostate cancer susceptibility gene at chromosome 17p. Nat Genet 2001;27:172–180.
crossref pmid
9. Ojala D, Montoya J, Attardi G. tRNA punctuation model of RNA processing in human mitochondria. Nature 1981;290:470–474.
crossref pmid
10. Brzezniak LK, Bijata M, Szczesny RJ, Stepien PP. Involvement of human ELAC2 gene product in 3' end processing of mitochondrial tRNAs. RNA Biol 2011;8:616–626.
crossref pmid
11. Sanchez MI, Mercer TR, Davies SM, Shearwood AM, Nygard KK, Richman TR, et al. RNA processing in human mitochondria. Cell Cycle 2011;10:2904–2916.
crossref pmid
12. Tsutsui H. Oxidative stress in heart failure: the role of mitochondria. Intern Med 2001;40:1177–1182.
crossref pmid
13. Chung YW, Kang SM. An experimental approach to study the function of mitochondria in cardiomyopathy. BMB Rep 2015;48:541–548.
crossref pmid pmc
Fig. 1

Serum lactic acid levels during hospitalization. Serum lactic acid levels were consistently above the upper normal limit (---) and varied with the patient's condition.

Fig. 2

(A) Direct sequencing of the proband and her father showing a novel heterozygous mutation of ELAC2 gene, c.95C>G (p.Pro32Arg). (B) The p.P32 amino acid is completely conserved across different species, which is shown in red box.

Table 1

Summary of the patients with ELAC2 gene mutation

Study Number of patients Zygosity ELAC2 gene Clinical features Course
Haack et al.5) (2013) German (2) Compound heterozygous c. 631C>T; 1559C>T (p.Arg211*; Thr520Ile) HCM, IUGR, psychomotor and growth retardation, muscular hypotonia, microcephaly, dysphagia Death at 6 months, alive at 2.10 years
Arabic (1) Homozygous c.460T>C (p.Phe154Leu) HCM, IUGR, muscular hypotonia Death at 11 months
Turkish (2) Homozygous c.1267C>T (p.Leu423Phe) HCM, DCM, psychomotor retardation, muscular hypotonia Alive at 13 years, death at 4.9 years
Akawi et al.6) (2016) Pakistani (5) Homozygous c.1423+2 T>A, splicing site mutation Intellectual disability, mild septal hypertrophy Alive at 2.5–19 years
Shinwari et al.7) (2017) Arabic (16) Homozygous c.460T>C (p.Phe154Leu) HCM or DCM, developmental delay, seizures Death at median age 4 months
Present case Korean (1) Heterozygous c.95C>G (p.Pro32Arg) Encephalopathy, cardiac anomaly, IUGR, growth retardation Death at 5 months

HCM, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy; IUGR, intrauterine growth retardation; DCM, dilated cardiomyopathy.

METRICS Graph View
  • 3 Crossref
  • 7 Scopus
  • 7,416 View
  • 152 Download