Article Contents
| Clin Exp Pediatr > Volume 68(11); 2025 |
|
Conflicts of interest
JK received honorarium from Abbott, Dexcom, and Medtronic. Except for that, no potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
| Model |
Currently available in Korea |
Future introduction |
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guardian 4 | Dexcom G7 | FreeStyle Libre 2 | Caresens Air | Simplera | FreeStyle Libre 3 | |
| Manufacturer | Medtronic | Dexcom Inc. | Abbott Diabetes Care | i-SENS, inc. | Medtronic | Abbott Diabetes Care |
| Type | Real time | Real time | Real time | Real time | Real time | Real time |
| Size (cm) | 2.9×3.6×1.0 | 3.4×3.7×0.5 | 1.4×1.4×0.2 | 3.5×1.9×0.5 | 2.9×2.9×0.5 | 0.8×0.8×0.1 |
| Age (yr) | ≥7 | ≥2 | ≥4 (2b)) | ≥19 (overseas: ≥18) | ≥2 | ≥4 (2c)) |
| Attachment area | 7–17 Yr: upper arm, upper buttocks 18–80 yr: upper arm, abdomen | 2–6 Yr: upper arm, abdomen, upper buttocks ≥7 yr: upper arm, abdomen | Upper arm | upper arm | 2–17 Yr: upper arm, upper buttocks ≥18 yr: upper ar | Upper arm |
| Transmitter | Reusable (12 months) | Integrated sensor/transmitter | Integrated sensor/transmitter | Integrated sensor/transmitter | Integrated sensor/transmitter | Integrated sensor/transmitter |
| Display device | Smartphone | Smartphone or receiver | Smartphone or receiver (reader) | Smartphone or receiver | Smartphone | Smartphone or receiver (reader) |
| Sensor duration (day) | 7 | 10 (15a)) | 14 (15b)) | 15 | 7 | 14 (15c)) |
| Calibration | No (factory-calibrated) | No (optional) | No (factory-calibrated) | No (optional) | U.S.: first 8 hr/ OUS: No | No (factory-calibrated) |
| Measurement range (mg/dL) | 40–400 | 40–400 | 40–400 | 40–500 | 40–400 | 40–400 |
| MARD, adult (%) | Upper arm 10.6, abdomen 10.8 | Upper arm 8.2, abdomen 9.1 | ≥18 Yr: 9.2 Pregnant woman: 11.6 | 9.4 | 10.2 | 7.8 |
| MARD, child (%) | Upper arm 11.7, upper buttocks 12.3 | 2–6 Yr: overall 9.3 7–17 yr: upper arm 8.1, abdomen 9.0 | 4–5 Yr: 11.8 6–17 yr: 9.7 | – | Upper arm 10.9, upper buttocks 10.2 | 7.8 |
| Warm-up time (min) | 120 | 30 | 60 | 30 | 120 | 60 |
| Alarm | High, low, predictive high/low | High, low, urgent low, urgent low soon (predict), falling/rising fast, delayed 1st | High, low, signal loss | High, low, very low, predictve high/low, rate of change, signal loss | High, low, urgent low, high/low predicted, fall/rise alert | High, low, signal loss |
| FDA-approved for insulin dosing | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Application (smartphone) | CareLink | Dexcom CLARITY, Follow, Pasta | LibreView | Caresens Air App | CareLink | LibreView |
| Website | https://carelink.medtronic.eu/login | https://clarity.dexcom.eu/ | https://libreview.com | https://sens365.i-sens.com | https://carelink.medtronic.eu/login | https://libreview.com |
| Medication interference | Acetaminophen, hydroxyurea | Acetaminophen, hydroxyurea | High dose vitamin C | High dose vitamin C | Acetaminophen, hydroxyurea | High dose vitamin C |
| Interworking with other medical devices | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Other features | Predictive alarm (up to 60 min in advance) | Temporary silencing for up to 6 hr, very low lag time averaging 3.5 min | IBO A-/M BPA-f r ee (improved dermatologic tolerability) | - | High predictive alarm (10–60 min in advance) | - |
CGM, continuous glucose monitoring; FDA, U.S. Food and Drug Administration; IBOA, isobornyl acetate; MARD, mean absolute relative difference; MBPA, 2,2'-methylenebis(6-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol) monoacrylate.
| Metric | Interpretation | Goals |
|---|---|---|
| Period of CGM use | ≥14 Day | |
| Active usage time percentage of CGM | ≥70% | |
| Mean glucose | Simple average of glucose values | <154 mg/dL |
| Glucose management indicator | Calculated value approximating HbA1c (not always equivalent) | <7% |
| Glycemic variability (%CV) target | Spread of glucose values | ≤36% |
| TAR: % >250 mg/dL | Level 2 hyperglycemia | <5% |
| TAR: % 181–250 mg/dL | Level 1 hyperglycemia | <25% |
| TIR: % 70–180 mg/dL | In range | >70% |
| TITR, % 70–140 mg/dLa) | In tight range | >50% |
| TBR: % 54–69 mg/dL | Level 1 hypoglycemia | <4% |
| TBR: % <54 mg/dL | Level 2 hypoglycemia | <1% |
| Source (study) | Study design (duration) | Treatment | Population | Baseline glycemic status | CGM device | Key outcomes | Main findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tamborlane et al., 2008 (JDRF CGM study) [22] | Multicenter RCT (26 wk) | MDI, CSII | Children (8–14 yr); n=114 (E/C 56/58), Adolescents (15–24 yr); n= 110 (E/C 57/53) | Mean HbA1c: 7.9–8.0% | rtCGM: Dexcom G7 , Mini Med Paradigm, FreeStyle Navigator | HbA1c change, CGM adherence, severe hypoglycemia | Children (8–14 yr): significant HbA1c reduction in CGM group with high adherence, Adolescents (15–24 yr): no significant HbA1c difference due to lower adherence |
| Kordonouri et al., 2010 (ONSET study) [23] | Multicenter RCT (12 mo) | CSII | Children with newly diagnosed T1D (1–16 yr), n=160 | NA | rtCGM: Enlite | HbA1c, glycemic variability, C-peptide, sensor usage | No overall HbA1c difference between groups; however, regular sensor users had significantly lower HbA1c (7.1% vs. 7.6%), reduced glycemic variability, and better C-peptide pre- servation (esp. in 12–16 yr subgroup) |
| Battelino et al., 2011 [24] | Multicenter RCT (6 mo) | MDI, CSII | Children (10–17 yr); n=53 (E/C 27/26) | Mean HbA1c 6.9% (all <7.5%) | rtCGM: FreeStyle Navigator | Hypoglycemia (<63 mg/ dL), HbA1c, TIR | Hypoglycemia <63 mg/dL reduced by 48%, HbA1c reduction (0.23%) |
| El-Laboudi et al., 20 16 (JDRF CGM study) [25] | RCT (26 wk) | MDI, CSII | Children (8–14 yr); n= 142 (E/C 74/68), Adolescents (15–24 yr); n=141 (E/C 71/70) | Mean HbA1c: 7.4% | rtCGM: Dexcom G7, Enlite, FreeStyle Navigator | Glycemic variability (CV, LBGI, %GRADEhypoglycemia, MAG), HbA1c | CGM significantly reduced most glycemic variability indices, especially CV, LBGI, %GRAD Ehypoglycemia . Glycemic variability better predicted hypoglycemia than HbA1c. Greater benefit in those with high baseline HbA1c, high baseline GV, frequent SMBG, and pump use |
| Laffel et al., 2020 (CITY study) [26] | RCT (26 wk) | MDI, CSII | Adolescents (14–19 yr); n=101 (E/C 48/53) | Mean HbA1c 8.9% | rtCGM: Dexcom G5 | HbA1c change, CGM metrics, satisfaction | Modest HbA1c reduction (–0.37%); 44% had ≥0.5% HbA1c drop |
| Laffel et al., 2021 (SENCE study) (2021) [27] | RCT (6 mo) | MDI, CSII | Children (2–8 yr), n=143 | Mean HbA1c 8.2% | rtCGM: Dexcom G5 | TIR, hypoglycemia, QoL | CGM did not improve TIR significantly vs BGM; however, CGM significantly reduced hypoglycemia (<70 mg/dL) |
| Elbalshy et al., 2022 (DIY RT-CGM study) [28] | RCT, Cross-over (17 wk) | MDI | Children (2–13 yr); n=55 (DIY-rtCGM/isCGM 28/27) | Mean HbA1c: 7.6% | DIY-rtCGM: isCGM+xDrip+, isCGM: FreeStyle Libre 1 | Parental FOH, TIR, treatment satisfaction | No FOH change; TIR increased 5.7%, parental satisfaction improved |
| Messaaoui et al., 2022 [29] | RCT (8 wk) | MDI, Free-mix, CSII | Children, adolescents, young adults (4–20 yr), n=37 (E/C 19/18) | Median HbA1c 7.8% | rtCGM: GuardianTM Connect, isCGM: FreeStyle Libre 1 | TBR, severe hypoglycemia, HbA1c, glycemic variability | No HbA1c change; however significant reduction in severe hypoglycemia in rtCGM group |
| Van Name et al., 2023 (SENCE 1-year follow-up) [30] | RCT+extension (12 mo total) | MDI, CSII | Children (2–8 yr), n=143 | Mean HbA1c 8.2% | rtCGM: Dexcom G5 | TIR, hypoglycemia, QoL | CGM did not improve TIR significantly vs BGM; however, CGM significantly reduced time <70 mg/dL (hypoglycemia) |
| Jefferies et al., 2023 [31] | Multicenter RCT (12 wk) | MDI, CSII | Children 4–13 yr, n=100 (E/C 49/51) | Mean HbA1c: 9.1% | isCGM: FreeStyle Libre 2 | HbA1c, TBR | No change in HbA1c or TIR; reduced TBR in isCGM group |
C, control; CGM, continuous glucose monitoring; CSII, continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion; CV, coefficient of variation; DIY, do-It-yourself; E, experiment; FOH, fear of hypoglycemia; GRADEhypoglycemia, glycemic risk assessment diabetes equation score attributable to hypoglycemia; HbA1c, glycated hemoglobin; isCGM, intermittently scanned; LBGI, low blood glucose index; MAG, mean absolute glucose change per unit time; MDI, multiple daily injection; NA, not available; QoL, quality of life; RCT, randomized controlled trials; rtCGM, real-time CGM; T1D, type 1 diabetes; TBR, time below range; TIR, time in range.